The Testament of Ann Lee

by Mike McGranaghan

Amanda Seyfried is long overdue to be recognized as one of our most interesting and talented actresses. The Testament of Ann Lee will hopefully change that. Coming hot on the heels of her box office smash The Housemaid, this historical musical-drama underlines Seyfried’s incredible range. The two pictures could not be more different in terms of tone or subject matter, but she rules in both of them.

Director Mona Fastvold turns the story, which is based on true events, into a captivating cinematic experience. The movie traces the rise of Ann Lee (Seyfried) among the religious group known as the Shakers. Their name, as we see, is inspired by the rapturous movements they make while singing hymns. Upon entering the group, Ann proves to be significantly moved by the spirit and quickly becomes an influential member, especially among those who believe Christ will make his Second Coming as a woman. She goes on to rattle the patriarchy by championing the causes of gender and social equality.

Lewis Pullman co-stars as Ann’s brother William, Thomasin McKenzie is Mary, a fellow Shaker who falls under her spell, and Christopher Abbott plays Abraham, the man she marries. When Ann comes to believe that sex is inherently sinful, conflict within the marriage begins.

As I said, The Testament of Ann Lee is a musical, although not a conventional one. The plot is moved forward by intricately choreographed musical numbers wherein the Shakers demonstrate the qualities that earned them their name. These sequences are stylized, given a slightly surreal vibe that suggests profound spiritual connection. Some have elegant moves; others are bursting at the seams with manic energy. All of them are driven by Seyfried’s beautiful, haunting vocals.

When not singing, the actress still dazzles. Her performance conveys how devout and determined Ann is. You completely understand why she inspires her fellow Shakers. Most impressively, Seyfried avoids any temptation to overact the part. She convinces us of this woman’s influence through a quiet intensity. Pullman, McKenzie, and Abbott provide excellent backup, each of them helping to bring added dimension to Ann’s journey.

The Testament of Ann Lee tackles unusual subject matter yet does so in a way that’s hypnotic. Rather than opting to be a traditional biopic, Fastvold gives the film weird edges that prevent it from being stuffy. Superb production design contributes to the impact, as the authentic locations and sets practically become characters of their own, especially when wild things happen within them.

Even if the Shaker Movement isn’t a topic that immediately grabs your attention, the bold storytelling choices – and Amanda Seyfried’s magnificent performance - have a way of pulling you in.

---